Sheboygan Fish Fry Guide

Find Sheboygan Fish frys here! Have a Sheboygan fish fry not included on this list? Please contact us to get your Sheboygan Fish Fry listed! #sheboyganfishfry

Sheboygan Fish Fry Guide

Have a Sheboygan Fish Fry not included on this list? Join our Sheboygan Fish Fry Guide today!

Vote Today for your Favorite Fish Frys!

Support your favorite restaurants in the Finley Awards! 

8th St Ale Haus

1132 N 8th St. Sheboygan 53081

Al and Al Stein Haus

1502 S. 12th St. Sheboygan 53081

All Season’s Family Restaurant

510 E Rhine St. #C Elkhart Lake 53020

Antoinette’s Casual Dining

18 West Mill St. Plymouth 53073

Beacon Restaurant(inside Blue Harbor Resort)

725 Blue Harbor Drive Sheboygan 53081

Black Pig

821 N 8th St. Sheboygan 53081

Blackwolf Run Restaurant

1111 Riverside Dr. Kohler 53044


2427 Calumet Dr. Sheboygan 53081

Chissy’s Pub and Grill

215 WI-28 Waldo 53093

DeO’s Pizzeria and Pub

417 E Mill St. Plymouth 53073

Fat Cow Pub and Eatery

406 Broadway St. Sheboygan Falls 53085

Five Pillars Supper Club-Restaurant and Banquet Halls

W2990 Cty Rd K Random Lake 53075

Frankie’s Pub and Grill

2218 Indiana Ave. Sheboygan 53081

Fudgienuckles Sports Pub

133 W. Main St. Glenbeulah 53023

Great Lakes Fish Company

819 Riverfront Dr. Sheboygan 53081

Greg’s Tap

409 E. Wisconsin St. Adell 53001

Harbor Lights on Lake Ellen

W6294 harbor Lights Rd. Cascade 53011

JW Creekside Bar and Restaurant

N1439 WI-28 Adell 53001

Keggers Pub and Grill

447 2nd St. Random Lake 53075

Knockouts Tap

1209 Millersville Ave Howards Grove 53083

Lakefront Cafe and Mexican Grill

417 2nd St. Random Lake 53075

Lakehouse bar and Restaurant

W6547 Cty Rd C Plymouth 53073

Leicht’s Waldo Cafe

235 Depot St. Waldo 53093

Leonard’s Silver Creek Inn

W6498 HWY 144 Random Lake 53075

Majerle’s Black River Grill

5033 Evergreen Dr. Sheboygan 53083

Manning Irish Pub

3015 N 15th St. Sheboygan 53081

Mary’s Country Grove Restaurant

322 Cty Rd. RR Cedar Grove 53013

Meyer’s Lakeview Pub

550 Wilson Ave Sheboygan 53081

Midway Eat

N529 WI-57 Random Lake 53075

Nap’s Place

N7105 Cty Rd C and J Plymouth 53073

NZ’s Bar and Grill

1022 Michigan Ave Sheboygan 53081

On The House

1153 High Ave Sheboygan 53081

Otto’s Restaurant (in the Osthoff Resort)

101 Osthoff Ave Elkhart Lake 53020

Parker John’s BBQ and Pizza

705 Riverfront Dr. Sheboygan 53081

Petek’s Tavern

2702 S. 8th St. Sheboygan 53081

PJ Campbells at the Depot

114 Depot Rd. Plymouth 53073

Ranieri’s Four of a Kind Bar and Grill

811 Indiana Ave Sheboygan 53081

Roadside Bar & Grill

925 N 8th St. Sheboygan 53081

Rupp’s Downtown

N5575 WI-57 Plymouth 53073

Scenic Bar and Restaurant

1635 Indiana Ave. Sheboygan 53081

Schwarz Fish Company

828 RIverfront Dr. Sheboygan 53081

Sherman Station

622 Maine Ave Adell 53001


4136 HWY 42 Sheboygan 53083

Siebkens Resort Pam’s

284 S. Lake St. Elkhart Lake 53020

Siebkens Resort Stop-Inn Tavern

284 S. Lake St. Elkhart Lake 53020

Sipp’s Bar and Grill

507 Madison Ave Cascade 53011

Sportsman’s Bar

436 S. Main St. Cedar Grove 53013

Strikes Bar and Grill(inside Lakeshore Lanes)

2519 S Business Dr. Sheboygan 53081

Sundance Saloon

1509 S. 12th St. Sheboygan 53081

The Fig and the Pheasant

301 E. Mill St. Plymouth 53073

The Horse & Plow

419 Highland Dr. Kohler 53044

The Northwestern House

1909 Union Ave Sheboygan 53081

The Twisted Pair

N1502 Cty Rd A Beechwood 53040

The Wisconsin Room

1504 Cty Rd A Adell 53001

Three Guys and a Grill

W7039 CR-SR Elkhart Lake 53020

Times Remembered Inc

102 Wisconsin St. Adell 53001


1231 N 8th St. Sheboygan 53081


552 S Evans St. Sheboygan 53081

Get FishFry Restaurant ideas in your inbox every week!

 Last week we used your guide to a VERY nice fish fry at a VERY nice place. We look forward to the next fish fry guide email! Half the fun is getting that email...the other half is deciding where we are going to go this week....then of course the experience of either trying a new place or revisiting one we've been to before. Again, thank you!